BOE Moves School Elections to November, Eliminates Budget Vote

Following signing of state law, the Board of Ed passed a resolution that shifts board elections and gets rid of annual budget referendum

The Lacey Township School District voted to move its board elections to November, which will eliminate the budget vote if spending plans remain under the state-mandated 2 percent tax levy cap.

“It’s the feelings of the board that this is the right thing to do,” President Jack Martenak said. “It saves us money in budget expenses and hopefully it will increase voter turnout for school board elections."

The school board joined many across the state in the switch, which will save the district approximately $20,000 in election costs.

The vote, which was unanimous, moves elections to the first Tuesday in November. Those board members who are up for re-election this year will remain on the board until November.

"It takes the issue of the school budget off of elections, which is the only budget that voters are allowed to vote on in the realm of federal, state, county, municipal and school budgets,” Martenak said.

A budget referendum will only be necessary if the board's budget exceeds the 2 percent tax levy cap. The move allows for more planning without the concern of a budget outcome, Martenak said.

But Martenak does not see that part of the law as much of a change as the school district proposed a zero percent increase in the tax levy for the last two years, he said.

The budget process will remain the same, Martenak said. A special meeting for the submission of the preliminary 2012-13 budget will be held on Monday, March 5 and the budget will be made available at a public hearing on Monday, March 26. Both meetings will be held in the high school's lecture hall at 6 p.m.

According to the law, moved to November, acting as filing officer for nomination petitions, ruling on objections to nominations and designing the set-up of the ballot.

A non-scientific Lacey Patch poll held in January revealed that 65 percent of readers supported the move.

Even though residents will not have the option to vote the budget down if the board remains under the cap, Lacey resident Tim O’Connor thought the move would be beneficial to the township.

“It’s been a long time coming,” he said. “The object is to control the board members. With more people involved [on election day], we’ll be able to do that.”

With greater voter turnout, residents will have ability to essentially control the budget by whom they vote in, he said.

Lanoka Harbor Elementary School Parent Teacher Organization President Carolyn Roselli previously said she does not have a firm stance on the issue but it may be beneficial to start with a budget in November with the same staff rather than issue a budget in April, as the school year comes to an end.

“[The board should do] anything that would be more beneficial to the students and would be helpful to the district in getting the things that the schools need,” Roselli, a teacher at a local preschool and parent of four children, said.

Central Regional, Manchester districts weigh in

Lacey is not the only area district that jumped at the chance to move its elections. Barnegat, Central Regional and Manchester have done the same.

"We don't have to go to the towns," said longtime  member  at her board's Jan. 19 board meeting. "That was so agonizing."

"It will give us a little more flexibility," board President Keith Buscio said. "In that respect, we gain a little more control that we had in the past."

Central Regional Schools Superintendent  said that the 2012-13 budget will be tight. Parlapanides had already begun gearing up to get the budget passed in April.

"We didn't know if this bill was going to pass or not," he said. "We've already scheduled 42 meetings with the senior communities and PTAs."

Business Administrator Kevin O'Shea said he didn't anticipate the district would go over a 2 percent increase for the budget's tax levy. That would help the district avoid repeats of last year's battles when the budget went down by 106 votes, requiring the governing bodies of all five of Central's sending towns – Berkeley, Ocean Gate, Island Heights, Seaside Heights and Seaside Park – to hammer out a tax cut all could live with.

Manchester Board of Education President Donald Webster said that when it came to an Election Day shift, "the pros outweigh the cons."

Webster said that although the board has "some reservations" with the law including how referendum votes will work and whether partisan politics could come into play, the changes should be beneficial. 

Webster said that in 1903 school board elections were legislated to be held in April to avoid the partisan politics associated with the general election. Manchester's municipal government has been nonpartisan since 1990.

Last year, as has happened in years past,  the Manchester school district's $50 million budget. A weeks-long process involving meetings between the township council and board of education led to a .

"This will be a big help for us," said Superintendent of Schools David Trethaway.

Based on several polls, the majority of Patch readers in Barnegat, Manchester and Toms River support moving board of education elections and forgoing the public vote on the budget. In a query on this site, 71 percent of respondents said they agreed with the move. A similar poll in Manchester showed 77 percent agreed. In Toms River, the margin was smaller – 57 percent said they would be OK with a November school election.

Breaking down the new school elections law

Patch's partners at NJ Spotlight shed some light on the subject of the new options for school districts when it comes to elections and budget approval. Check out their full story here.

What it is: Gov. Chris Christie signed into law a bill that would allow school districts to move their board and budget elections to November and eliminate budget votes entirely for spending that falls within the new 2 percent tax cap. While the law makes such a move optional, it is arguably the most significant change to the way New Jersey residents have voted on school taxes since such a system was first enacted in 1903. The option is effective immediately, and a spokesman of the school boards association said it expects a "good number" of districts to take it.

The lure: The big attraction is that if a district moves the vote to November, it would eliminate school votes entirely for those budgets within the cap, taking away the uncertainty that grips most budgets each year when its fate — no matter the increase or even sometimes decrease — rests on a few voters.

The exception: Even if moved to November, voters would still have a say on budgets when they exceeded the cap. Districts would have to propose that excess spending as a separate ballot question, with no ability to appeal in the case of rejection.

The trade-off: The reluctance comes in the politics of moving school board elections to the prime time of November. With state and even federal offices also on the ballot, that brings a lot more voters to the polls, addressing the notoriously low turnout of April elections. But it also could make them far more partisan, raising concern that the election would be even more political than they are. There has also been opposition from some quarters to eliminating the school budget vote for even those within cap, claiming the voters should still have a say on what is the largest piece of their tax bill.

Catherine Galioto, Graelyn Brashear, Gregory Kyriakakis, Patricia Miller contributed to this report.

Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 01:18 PM
A little risky to grant the School Board an automatic 2% increase every year. However, voter “turn out” in the past for School Board Elections and the Budget has been poor at best. The budget has seen greater increases in past years! Now we need to examine the School Board Members Elections to appoint individuals who will balance the needs of the residents and the children.
TRM February 07, 2012 at 03:11 PM
I have never been in favor of letting the people vote the school budget up or down. I always thought the BOE should pass the budget - if your not happy with the budget then vote the members out. Too many times I have seen peo0ple vote the budget down but leave the members on the board- makes no sense to me. While we have had our schoolbudget battles here in Lacey for the most part the people have supported the school district, unlike the central regional school district which hasn't had a school budget passed in something like 25 years.
TRM February 07, 2012 at 03:13 PM
Tim is that your guess on what the monies are earning or did the BOE say that? Usually with that kinda of monies the banks give you a higher intrest rate!
Oscar Wilde February 07, 2012 at 03:38 PM
and that 2% increase will be year after year after year , as your house property value continues to drop just another christie lie
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 04:38 PM
@Mr. Smith : In additional; is while those funds were in the bank, we were receiving 0.4% intrest. Meanwhile we were paying 4% interest on the money. This is based on what the board stated in open public school board meetings.
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 04:39 PM
You just got the notice in the mail. Lower your taxes with an appeal of your tax assessment.
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 04:43 PM
Vote and elect new members to the BOE! Let's take back control of the board and start to cut the budget. The teachers have had control of the board for to long.
TRM February 07, 2012 at 05:04 PM
Tim what ideas do you have for the BOE ? Where did you get intrest rate of 0.4%, did the BOE tell you that number? Most banks when you deposit 3-4 million give you a higher intrest rate !
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 06:03 PM
@trm; the first goal is to give Dr. Brower a chance to develope her transition plan. We got so much last year we need to give the changes a little time. Next replace the old board members.
TRM February 07, 2012 at 06:33 PM
Tim, Okay about Dr Brower, I think everybody would agree with that so I'll leave that alone for now. but answer my other question where did you get 0.4% intrest rate ?
TRM February 07, 2012 at 08:39 PM
@JS not only does he change his postion often - he has tendancey to take liberties with his comments
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 09:04 PM
Sorry guys, my goal is to skake the hold of the entrenched good old boys. SIMPLE! We need good people from both parties to step up. Your funny, thinking only your buddies can do the job.
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 10:28 PM
Well I don't know about you guys but I am talking about moving the BOE election to November and getting rid of the GOOD OLD BOY ENTRENCHED BOE MEMBERS TOO! Only teachers and parents with children in the district vote or so it would seem. What are you talking about?
Tim O'Connor February 07, 2012 at 11:24 PM
You have completely lost me? What are you talking about?
Karen Binkwaters February 14, 2012 at 02:44 AM
I just learned I will am obligated to repay the IRS $15,000 plus this current year. I frantically went around calling legal professionals and certified public accountants yet I was not certain who to hire and could not pay for the "retainer costs." Then I came across ConsumerTaxReports.Org and was astonished at all the groundwork they had performed. Just about every major agency I was glancing at was already evaluated with a large check list explaining their expert services, pricing, track record, and even more! This web site is critical for individuals much like me. http://www.ConsumerTaxReports.org
Silver dollar February 14, 2012 at 03:34 AM
Karen Good way to get your add accross Just read it in the Hartland patch in M I but there it was $40,000 owed also read it in the Johnston patch in Iowa there it happen last year didnt go to the several other patches you used your add in but good way to get all these lawyers names out there Have a nice day thanks for google your name comes up quite a lot


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something