Community Corner
Site of Former Rite Aid Leaves Haunting Legacy
Daughter of former sheriff reportedly haunts 138 South Main Street
Though the former Rite Aid located on South Main Street in Forked River is now closed, spooky occurrences at the site are well-remembered by former employees of the store, as well as Eleanor Ditton and Virginia Schoenberg, both members of the Lacey Historical Society.
Ditton and Schoenberg both explained that a hotel named the Parker House was constructed there in the 1880’s, and was owned by Sheriff Joseph Parker. Sheriff Parker had a daughter named Josephine Parker Applegate, who suffered an untimely demise on Oct. 10, 1903.
Despite Ms. Parker Applegate being laid to rest over a century ago in the Good Luck Cemetery on Haines Street East in Forked River, it was widely speculated that her spirit continued to pervade the premises of the Parker House – even as it later transitioned into another hotel, the Greyhound Inn. The inn was named for the greyhound dogs raised by the father of Schoenberg’s cousin, Mahala Landrum.
Find out what's happening in Laceywith free, real-time updates from Patch.
“Guests at the Greyhound Inn would claim that they saw Josephine, or felt her presence,” Ditton recalled. “They would say they saw doors open and close at will, among other things.” After the Greyhound Inn burned down in a 1968 structure fire, Rite Aid later occupied the South Main Street location. However, employees soon learned that they weren’t the only ones present after hours.
“People who worked at the Rite Aid would say they saw doors open and close for no visible reason, boxes moved, and cash registers opened on their own,” Ditton explained.
Find out what's happening in Laceywith free, real-time updates from Patch.
Schoenberg added that employees who were working late hours at the store stocking shelves were reportedly some of Josephine’s favorite people to play tricks on. “Objects would move on the shelves with no apparent cause, the phone would ring and no one would be on the other end of the line, things like that.”
Both Ditton and Schoenberg felt sure in their belief that no matter what business occupies 138 South Main Street in the future, they too will also have a regular, mischievous visitor from beyond the grave. “I’m sure that she’ll continue to be here. That was her home, I don’t think she’ll leave,” Schoenberg stated.
Recently, the to open at the site in the coming months.
